Hand-picked places to eat, stay, shop & cook in the South West

Restaurant review: Old Mill Bistro, near Padstow

Home » Good stuff » Restaurant review: Old Mill Bistro, near Padstow

If you’re looking for the wow-factor of fine dining with all the low-key charm of a cosy bistro, the Old Mill Bistro is likely to become your smug little secret, writes Rosanna Rothery

Old Mill Bistro

Already a firm favourite with foodies-in-the-know, the family-run bistro, headed up by Adam Tomlinson, recently added Jamie Porter to its ranks: a Cornish chef who earned his stripes in the kitchens of Rick Stein and Alain Roux.

VISIT for utter reliability. It’s not always easy trying to pick something scrumptious from a menu when you’re ravenous as a wolf, a little tiddly post aperitif and trying to engage in witty repartee with a dining partner. ‘Am I going to end up coveting my companion’s dinner?’ is every foodie’s fear. Thankfully, whether you prefer to play it safe or throw caution to the wind, you won’t be infected by green-eyed muncher syndrome at this bistro housed within The Old Mill House B&B.

Those opting for a classic surf-and-turf, for instance, will feel rather pleased with themselves for choosing a dish that pairs the briny freshness of panfried hake with chorizo. As if hankering after the sea, the pearlescent fish laps up the saltiness of the cured meat while the accompanying mussels smell as heady as a wave crashing on a rock.

For those pushing out the culinary boat, the delicate flavours of dover sole are complemented by chicken, cep and truffle in a creamy overcoat of agnolotti (ravioli’s smaller, squarer cousin).

As this is Cornwall, it’s only natural to find the menu spilling over with seafood, although meat eaters will find options like wood pigeon, steak and duck. And it’s gratifying that absolutely everything (from the crusty tomato and thyme mini loaves to the decadently gooey chocolate brownie and petit four) has been handcrafted with the clear aim of perfection.

DON’T VISIT for showy dining in lofty surrounds. The beauty of this 24-cover eatery (where the table is yours for the evening) is its intimate charm and the friendly personal service.

WE LIKED the old-world feel of the 16th century corn mill, complete with working water wheel, which is lent picture-book charm by its proximity to an ancient bridge and babbling creek.

INSIDER’S TIP You can give in to the temptations of the gin menu as cottage-style bedrooms with original features beckon.

What we ate (dinner)

Starter Panfried scallops, apricot and szechuan puree, hog’s pudding, crispy chicken skin
Main Panfried dover sole, chicken, cep and truffle agnolotti, button mushroom, shellfish sauce
Pud Blackberry and szechuan pannacotta, glazed figs, praline, blackberry

3 courses from £21


As featured in food Magazine’s Winter 2019 issue. 

Also try


A secluded insider’s find just off the A39.

the basement

Wading through Padstow’s flood of restaurants, Abi Manning discovers an unassuming harbourside jewel

The Mill House Tintagel

Set in a secluded wooded valley, the 18th century Mill House is a cosy nest from which to explore this mystical corner of Cornwall’s rugged coast